This ranking is more or less by nuts blown, because we can argue looks, personality, etc but my dick does not lie. A lot of retirees (and one past-tense) here but I'm old lol.
1. Brie: My OG, discovered her in Dimensions (paper) magazine 30+ years ago and my blind was mown. I'd enjoyed BBW erotica previously but I'd never seen a model in any context with a shape like hers. Nirvana as she blew up by 150+ pounds over the next 15 years and went from the demure Girl Next Door who wouldn't even wear a bikini all the way to hardcore. Bummer about her WLS but she owes me nothing at this point.
2. Goddess Patty: RIP. Amazing blow-up (350 > 600+), pretty face, fantastic "papple" shaped body, fun attitude, sexy Latina voice, down with feedism and other fetish aspects. She's the gal you see falling out of her clothes as she waddles her way from the car to the food truck, huffing and puffing and then ordering half the menu, making super-hot jokes about her size the whole time.
3. Rennaye: I know she's controversial but she just does it for me. Pretty face, wonderful roly-poly body that's still feminine despite ridiculous size, yet another stunning blow-up (300 > 600+), and IMO video for video, the best feeder content — knows what she is and what we want. Totally nuts but that's why she's willing to go so extreme.
4. Valerie: Insane pear-shape, odd but cute face (I'm a sucker for big noses specifically), and a sexy shy personality — the opposite of a bitter, burnt-out pro. Relatively small but notable blow-up during her brief mid-career hiatus is the cherry on top. She works at the city clerk's office behind a plexiglass window. You think she's kind of attractive as you walk up and tell her the forms you need. She says "hang on a second" and gets up with unusual effort and you're like HOLY SHIT as she reveals that leviathan ass and you watch her wobble away.
5. Asshley: Another model I got to watch go from the mid-200s to 400+. Fertility goddess pear shape, boobs and arms as well as hips, thighs and butt, and jiggly as hell — no muscle tone detected. Cute ethnic face (see: big noses, above), and perky, girl next door personality.
6. Jenni: I have a thing for pears, obv, and she's the queen. Obv I also have a thing for demure yet confident women and she's got that as well.
7. Brianna: Pears uber alles, sure, but a 20-something mocha mountain of pure blubber will do it for me in just about any configuration. Specifically I love her mounds of back fat and freakishly large FUPA, gorgeous face, and joyful, candid feedee attitude. Girl waddling breathless around the mall you have to keep telling yourself not to stare at or follow so security doesn't ask you to leave.
8. Lailani: Controversy over her numbers games, but no denying she went through a fantastic blow-up over the years. And somehow she's almost as sexy deflated. Gorgeous yet natural face, sublime fertility goddess body, and up for just about everything.
9. Diva: Jaw-dropping pear bod that's only gotten bigger and more ridick in its proportions. Pretty face, great sexy "church mama" attitude — Bible in one hand and your dick in the other.
10. Cajun Big EZ: Dark horse on this list, which is why she's last. Notably smaller than the rest, even at her biggest, and with a face that's, to put it kindly, an acquired taste. But again — this is about sheer nuts delivered, not objectivity, so she belongs. The best I can explain is that you stop in Waffle House on a long road trip and she's the lady two booths away arguing with her redneck husband. A little homely but achingly sexy nonetheless, with that gigantic ass you know the husband is gonna pound half to heaven later that night.