I’m in the same spot man. I love my girlfriend and she IS hot to me. But I can’t shake the feeling that I’d be more aligned with what I want with a bigger girl. She has a history with eating disorders though and, while she accepts me for having this kink, doesn’t want anything to do with it. And she freaks out about her weight at her relatively skinny weight now. I can’t imagine how she’d handle more. There are other issues too so I am considering leaving but I really do love her for who she is regardless of our problems. My current answer is to just stay unless the other issues get worse or she leaves me. And in one of those cases I find a fat girl who’ll love me. and if things stay good, then I’ll just suck it up. not sure if there’s a better way here